‘Star Wars’ Fans Debate Controversial Gina Carano After Lucasfilm Announcement

in Star Wars

gina carano as cara dune

Credit: Gina Carano Instagram

If you were following along during the airing of The Mandalorian Season 2 in 2020 and into early 2021, you undoubtedly already know that former Cara Dune actress Gina Carano found herself in hot water more than once due to her controversial Tweets regarding various social and political topics.

Gina Carano as Cara Dune holding a blaster
Credit: Lucasfilm

Related: Ex-‘Mandalorian’ Star Gina Carano Flips Off the Entire Internet, “Cancel This”

Carano was officially fired from the Star Wars franchise in February 2021 after hashtags like #FireGinaCarano#WeLoveCaraDune, and #IStandWithGinaCarano alternately trended on social media for months. As a result of the actress’s dismissal from the Star Wars universe, her Mandalorian spinoff series, Rangers of the New Republic, was taken out of active development.

carl weathers, jon favreau, kathleen kennedy, gina carano, dave filoni, and pedro pascal take a selfie
Credit: Daniel Boczarski/WireImage for Disney

Related: ‘Mandalorian’ Star Opens up About Disney’s Stance on Supporting Free Speech

This week, Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy confirmed that the show has been officially canceled, though did not that certain plot points will come into play in The Mandalorian Season 3 and other spinoffs, such as Ahsoka and The Book of Boba Fett, which is due to hit Disney+ on December 29, 2021.

Carano has been vocal about her distaste for The Walt Disney Company and Lucasfilm, Ltd., publicly stating that she was “bullied” by the powers-that-be and sharing that her new project — a Western film — with Ben Shapiro’s Daily Wire will “take down the Death Star”.

bryce dallas howard (left) and gina carano (right) on mandalorian set
Credit: Lucasfilm

Related: “I Hear You”: Filoni Responds to Fans’ Call to Save ‘Clone Wars’

Despite this, Carano’s supporters called for the former women’s MMA and Muay Thai fighter to return to the Star Wars story — and a new rumor indicates she could be back for The Mandalorian Season 4 thanks to support from showrunner Jon Favreau, leading man Pedro Pascal (Din Djarin), and Giancarlo Esposito (Moff Gideon).

the mandalorian season 2 mission to morak (l-r) bill burr as migs mayfeld, gina carano as cara dune, ming-na wen as fennec shand, pedro pascal as din djarin, and temuera morrison as boba fett
Credit: Lucasfilm

Related: Actress Got “Hit in the Face” With Tennis Balls to Learn Bo-Katan Lines

Now, Kennedy’s confirmation that Rangers will still play into the “Mando-verse” in some way has fans online debating whether or not Carano could actually be plotting her Star Wars return. And, unsurprisingly, the Mandalorian fandom is quite divided in whether or not they think this should occur.

A Twitter user named RyGuy responded to The Direct’s post, writing:

Thanks Gina for screwing the fans out of the series #GinaCarano

Related: ‘Star Wars’ Fans Suddenly Wish Luke Skywalker Cameo Hadn’t Happened

DustierPlague responded to the same post, clearly not thrilled about Carano being fired from the space opera franchise:

Or you could just rehire Gina Carano

Related: ‘Star Wars’ Fans Are Freaking Out Over Grogu’s Official Lightsaber

Daniel Skywalker is firmly on the other side of the Gina Carano debate, sharing:

We really dodged a bullet here. Just imagine a whole show carried by Gina Carano’s “acting skills”.

#StarWars

Related: ‘Star Wars’ Just Unraveled Everything We Knew About Boba Fett

Proving that fans still have wildly different opinions about the daughter of NFL quarterback Glenn Carano, Kendalorian posted:

Please @Lucasfilm_Ltd bring back @ginacarano for The Mandalorian! She was perfect in the role as Cara Dune and really brought an important aspect of body positivity, and frankly just pure positivity that is missing from a lot of Star Wars. My nieces love her dearly.

Jalbrit responded to a suggestion that Carano could simply be recast:

They will not recast. Favreau created the character based solely on Gina Carano. There was no audition. If any other actress put on that outfit and call herself Cara Dune she would be mocked beyond believe.

Related: Timothy Olyphant Teases Cobb Vanth’s ‘Mandalorian’ Return

It is worth noting that Lucasfilm has already confirmed they will not recast Cara Dune, meaning that if the New Republic Marshal were to return to Nevarro alongside Greef Karga (Carl Weathers), Carano would be the one to portray the character.

What do you think? Will Gina Carano ever come back into the Star Wars fold?

View Comments (114)