Should Margot Robbie’s ‘Pirates’ Movie Be a Spinoff or Reboot?

in Movies & TV

margot robbie and johnny depp

Credit: Margot Robbie Instagram/Disney

Margot Robbie — star of Birds of Prey — will set sail in a new female-fronted Pirates of the Caribbean movie, but it should be a spinoff of the now-iconic franchise instead of a reboot.

Pirates Of The Caribbean
Credit: Disney

Related: Should Disney Parks Remove Depp From Pirates? Guests Speak Out

There’s been a flurry of news surrounding actor and Disney Legend Johnny Depp and his famed Captain Jack Sparrow role in recent months. Since Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003), Depp has served as the star of the $4.5 billion franchise, appearing in a total of five films.

Disney even added Jack Sparrow animatronics to the Pirates of the Caribbean ride at Disneyland Resort, Walt Disney World Resort, Disneyland Paris, and Tokyo Disneyland. The version of the ride that Guests can ride at Shanghai Disneyland features even more, theming from the movie franchise.

Pirates of the Caribbean
Credit: Disney

What’s going on with Johnny Depp?

Depp, unfortunately, has had a challenging time of it recently. The Pirates of the Caribbean and Fantastic Beasts star and his fans have had a turbulent year, especially after Johnny Depp lost his libel lawsuit against U.K. News Group newspaper publication, The Sun.

In 2018, The Sun reported that Depp abused his ex-wife Amber Heard (Zack Snyder’s Justice League) on various occasions throughout their relationship. In the wake of his court loss last fall, Depp was ultimately fired from Disney’s Pirates franchise and Warner Bros. Fantastic Beasts films.

 Birds of Prey
Credit: DC / Warner Bros

Related: Depp Back on Board? Disney Reportedly Considers Petition for Actor’s Return!

Last June, The Walt Disney Company announced that Margot Robbie would star in a female-led Pirates of the Caribbean movie with Birds of Prey writer Christina Hodson. It’s reported that the film will be a reboot of the pre-existing Pirates franchise, but it would fare much better as a spinoff, in this writer’s opinion.

It is important to note that Disney has not officially confirmed the plot of the upcoming Pirates of the Caribbean 6 installment.

pirates of the caribbean jack sparrow holding gun
Credit: Disney

Pirates of the Caribbean has developed a devoted fandom over its nearly 20 years of movie history — it’s not quite on the level of Star Wars, but people love these characters. The franchise has gained a massive following, and Jack Sparrow is a fan-favorite character for many fans. In fact, over half a million supporters have signed a petition for Depp’s return to Pirates.

However, combined with the relatively lackluster — compared to the success of other movies in the series — Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales (2017) and Johnny Depp’s chaotic personal life, Disney decided to part ways with the actor.

Pirates of the Caribbean
Credit: Disney

Related: 500K Disney Fans Want Depp Back For ‘Pirates 6’

More on Margot Robbie’s Pirates of the Caribbean

Fans were split when news broke that Margot Robbie would lead a reported reboot of the Pirates franchise, particularly that the new movie will not be connected to previous installments of the series.

To completely scrap the beloved movies and their characters — including Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) — would disservice fans and do more harm than good to patch up Johnny Depp’s tumultuous career at the moment.

depp and keira knightley
Credit: Disney

Our very own Kelly Coffey put this situation perfectly:

“As a huge Johnny Depp fan, and lover of all things ‘Pirates’, I would love to see Margot Robbie’s POTC be a spin-off rather than a continuation of the films in the franchise.
Personally, I feel as though regardless of what is happening in Depp’s personal life, you can’t have the ‘Pirates’ films continue without Depp’s Jack Sparrow. And let’s just say Disney did want to continue the films with a Jack Sparrow character in the films, no one can ever replace Depp as the character.
So having Robbie come in as part of a spin-off rather than a continuation of the already-successful franchise is a great idea as she can have her very own storyline instead of competing and living up to the standards of the already successful films.”
Margot Robbie is a fantastic actress and is a huge box-office draw. Gaining an Oscar nod for her groundbreaking roles in Bombshell (2019) and I, Tonya (2017) solidified the Australian actress as a Hollywood heavy-hitter. Her upcoming portrayal of Harley Quinn in James Gunn’s The Suicide Squad (2021) is sure to steal the hearts of DC fans and further boost her credibility as an actress with a wide range of abilities.
Her future involvement with Disney and Pirates could still occur in the pre-existing franchise and introduce new characters while respecting previous ones. Rather than rebranding Jack Sparrow as Margot Robbie’s character, her pirate role could center around the infamous “Redhead” pirate from the attractions or even an entirely new one.
'Birds of Prey'
Credit: DC / Warner Bros
Without a doubt, Robbie would nail a portrayal of a pirate because, well, she just could. But, essentially, re-writing Captain Jack Sparrow without Johnny Depp is like trying to replace Harry Potter or Indiana Jones with a different actor.
Inside the Magic’s Krysten Swensen made a great point:
“I absolutely loved the first 3! Thought they were great. 4 and 5 seemed to really push it and probably could have been left out, though Dead Men Tell No Tales was a great subtitle. I think if they try to keep going with the Pirates movies, it will just seem as though they are beating a dead horse.”
'Pirates of the Caribbean'
Credit: Disney

Related: Johnny Depp’s ‘Pirates’ Considered “Doomed to Fail”

All good franchises must end at some point — and perhaps Pirates of the Caribbean should have ended with At World’s End or On Stranger Tides.

It’s reported that Johnny Depp has expressed a new sense of interest and awareness in portraying his Jack Sparrow character once more, and there is, of course, a slim chance that the petition we previously mentioned could impact casting decisions.

Pirates of the Caribbean
Credit: Disney
No matter where you stand with the Johnny Depp saga, one fact cannot be ignored: Johnny Depp is a fantastic actor. Depp, in a way, single-handedly created a “feel-good movie” franchise that you can’t help but watch. That being said, the actors following him with the Pirates franchise will have big shoes (or should I say “boots”) to fill.
Do you think that Margot Robbie’s movie should be a spinoff or reboot? Let us know in the comments below!
Editor’s Note: The opinions expressed in this article are not necessarily the opinions of Inside the Magic overall.

View Comments (2)