Honest Review: ‘Hocus Pocus’ Nestle Toll House Cookies

in Food

hocus pocus cookies

Credit: Kelly C. ITM

Spooky season is upon us, and I am so ready to celebrate.

I’ve already begun watching some of my favorite Halloween movies, shorts, and TV shows including Mickey’s House of VillainsHaunted Mansion, Disney’s Halloween Treatand, of course, Hocus Pocus!

This year, Nestle Toll House released a new Hocus Pocus-themed cookie dough so I decided to try it out to complete my Hocus Pocus movie night this weekend. But I know sometimes people hesitate on trying something new — so that’s why I wanted to write an honest review of these cookies before you go out and buy them yourselves!

Hocus Pocus Cookies

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

First of all — the packaging is so cute! The Sanderson Sisters are front and center and you definitely get Halloween vibes from the coloring. (They do say people eat with their eyes first, so this is super important for marketing purposes, and I think they nailed it!)

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

The cookie dough itself is oatmeal peanut butter and it is already pre-cut into squares. The entire block of cookie dough is topped with Reese’s Pieces scattered throughout.

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

As you break these cookies apart, the Reese’s Pieces do tend to fall off so once they are on the cookie sheet, just press them back in. But now, let’s get baking!

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

The directions tell you to pre-heat the oven to 325°F and to place the cookies approximately 2 inches apart. I found the cookies didn’t expand too much as they baked, but it’s still good not to place them too close together, otherwise you’ll end up with a big pile of mush.

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

The directions call for a cooking time of 13-15 minutes and this really all depends on 1. your oven and 2. your preference. If you like your cookies a bit on the raw side, definitely put them in for 13 minutes. However, if you like your cookies well done, I recommend the 15 minutes of bake time.

I baked these cookies for 14 minutes and they came out perfectly.

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

Be sure to let them cool on the cookie sheet before transferring to a place or cooling rack, otherwise they will instantly break and fall apart.

Let’s get to tasting!

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

I love when my cookies are fresh out of the oven so I tried one of these immediately and wow — they did NOT disappoint!

Warm, gooey, and absolutely delicious. If you are a fan of peanut butter — I highly recommend trying these cookies out for your next Hocus Pocus movie night.

One thing I do recommend though is if these cookies sit out and cool down, you miss out on that warm and gooeyness. So if this is how you prefer your cookies, be sure to pop them back in the microwave just for 10 seconds to warm them back up. Good as new!

And if you are looking for something to wash down these delicious cookies, be sure to try the Witches Brew, which you can find the recipe for by clicking here.

hocus pocus cookies
Credit: Kelly C. ITM

More on Hocus Pocus

You can watch Hocus Pocus on Disney’s streaming service, Disney+. The official description of the popular Halloween film reads:

After moving to Salem, Mass., teenager Max Dennison (Omri Katz) explores an abandoned house with his sister Dani (Thora Birch) and their new friend, Allison (Vinessa Shaw). After dismissing a story Allison tells as superstitious, Max accidentally frees a coven of evil witches (Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, Kathy Najimy) who used to live in the house. Now, with the help of a magical cat, the kids must steal the witches’ book of spells to stop them from becoming immortal.

If you are not yet signed up for Disney’s streaming service, you can subscribe online here.

Have you tried these Hocus Pocus cookies before? What did you think? Let us know in the comments below.

View Comments (2)