Southwest Passenger Dies After Being Mistaken as Unruly, Airline Wins Lawsuit

in Travel

Southwest Airlines disney world plane

Credit: Southwest Airlines

Several years ago, a Southern California man on a Southwest Airlines flight was mistaken as unruly when he was actually dying.

southwest plane on tarmac
Credit: Southwest Airlines

Related: Delta Airlines Officially Proposes a NEW No-Fly List For Unruly Passengers

Now, the carrier has somewhat surprisingly won a lawsuit in regard to the case. The Orange County Register reports:

Southwest Airlines cannot be sued over the death of a passenger whose distress was mistaken for unruly behavior by a flight crew out of Oakland, a California appeals court said.

The ruling Wednesday [June 8, 2022] upheld a trial court’s decision concerning Newport Beach resident Rich Ilczyszyn, 46, who suffered a fatal pulmonary embolism while on a flight from Oakland to Orange County on Sept. 19, 2014.

His family had filed a wrongful-death suit against Southwest and the flight crew, saying Ilczyszyn died because the crew failed to provide assistance.

Southwest Airlines disney world plane
Credit: Southwest Airlines

Related: Disney World Travelers Held In Plane After Returning to Canada, Unable to Leave

Ilczyszyn, a well-known financial trader, the found of iiTrader, and a regular guest on CNBC’s Futures Now, left behind a wife, Kelly — who had been a Southwest flight attendant for 15 years — and a daughter who was 9 years old at the time. He also had two grown children from a prior marriage.

During the flight in question, flight attendants heard Ilczyszyn making “grunting, growing, [and] crying” noises in the bathroom. Instead of providing assistance, they presumed him to be unruly and considered his behavior to be “a threat.” The flight crew declared a lockdown and asked that law enforcement take Ilczyszyn into custody upon landing.

Southwest Airlines
Credit: Southwest Airlines

Related: Orlando Airport Reminds Disney Guests of Their “FastPass” System

Ultimately, the team realized that the passenger had suffered a potentially fatal medical emergency. He was taken to the hospital, where he died the next day.

Per the OC Register, “an autopsy listed the cause as pulmonary thromboembolism due to “deep venous thrombosis,” a blood clot.”

southwest face mask
Credit: Southwest Airlines

Related: Spirit and Frontier Airlines to Merge Into a “Disruptive” Airline

The news outlet went on to share details about the original 2019 trial:

…witnesses for Southwest testified that it was unlikely Ilczyszyn could have survived even if the flight crew had been able to get to him. Southwest also claimed immunity under federal code because its employees were responding to a suspected security threat.

A witness for the plaintiffs testified that flight attendants “breached the standard of care” by failing to realize Ilczyszyn was in medical distress, and another contended he could have been resuscitated.

Now that Ilczyszyn’s family has lost their appeal, it is unknown what the next step in the legal proceedings will be.

face mask southwest baby
Credit: Ali Cleek/Instagram

Related: Lucky Travelers Just Got to Ride on United’s AMAZING ‘Star Wars’ Jet

This is not the first time a Southwest flight crew has come under fire. At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, a mom traveling home from Walt Disney World Resort on a Southwest Airlines flight was told to “glue” a face mask to her toddler’s face.

The situation went viral and the popular carrier faced backlash for the situation.

What do you think about this situation? Is Southwest culpable?

Ready to fly the friendly skies again? Visit the official Disney World website to plan your next magical vacation to Walt Disney World Resort’s four theme parks — Magic Kingdom, EPCOT, Disney’s Animal Kingdom, and Disney’s Hollywood Studios — and the Disney Springs shopping and dining district OR the official Disneyland website to plan your trip to Disneyland Resort’s two theme parks — Disneyland Park and Disney California Adventure Park — and the Downtown Disney District!

View Comments (22)