It’s Over: Disney World’s Last Effort To Save Itself Comes Crashing Down

in Walt Disney World

Mickey Mouse at Walt Disney World Resort as part of the 50th Anniversary Celebration

Credit: Disney

For decades, Disney World has stood as the pinnacle of theme park experiences, offering magical moments and unforgettable rides.

However, in recent years, it has faced mounting competition from Universal Studios, which has been making significant strides toward capturing a larger share of the market. Universal’s latest venture, Epic Universe, along with its numerous additions and updates, has put considerable pressure on Disney to innovate and maintain its dominance.

A large, colorful archway sign welcomes visitors to Walt Disney World, featuring its iconic slogan "The Most Magical Place on Earth." The road leading to the entrance is lined with palm trees and includes an image of Mickey Mouse. The sky is partly cloudy.
Credit: Inside the Magic

Despite these efforts, Disney’s latest rides, including TRON Lightcycle / Run and Tiana’s Bayou Adventure, have not been well received, leading many to question the future of the once-unrivaled theme park giant.

Universal Studios has been steadily chipping away at Disney’s market share with a series of strategic moves. The introduction of The Wizarding World of Harry Potter was a game-changer, drawing in massive crowds and setting a new standard for immersive theme park experiences.

The success of this venture emboldened Universal to continue expanding and enhancing its offerings. With the highly anticipated opening of Epic Universe, Universal is poised to further challenge Disney’s supremacy. This new park promises groundbreaking attractions, innovative technologies, and immersive environments that have already generated significant buzz and excitement among theme park enthusiasts.

Nighttime view of a futuristic, blue-lit pedestrian bridge bustling with people, featuring a distinctive arched design and glowing light spheres.
Credit: Becky Burkett

In contrast, Disney’s latest efforts have struggled to achieve similar levels of enthusiasm. TRON Lightcycle / Run, which opened with great fanfare, was met with mixed reviews. While some praised its thrilling ride mechanics and futuristic design, others criticized its short duration and lack of narrative depth. This lukewarm reception was a warning sign that Disney’s strategy needed reevaluation.

The latest blow to Disney’s reputation comes from Tiana’s Bayou Adventure, which replaced the beloved Splash Mountain. This reimagined ride was supposed to be a testament to Disney’s commitment to diversity and inclusion, celebrating the story of Princess Tiana from The Princess and the Frog (2009). However, the execution has left much to be desired, and the ride has faced a torrent of criticism on social media.

A whimsical nighttime scene in Magic Kingdom's newest attraction features riders in a log flume approaching a lively animal band playing on a wooden dock. A woman in explorer attire stands smiling by a tree, and two green frogs sit on a lily pad in the water dotted with pink flowers.
Credit: Disney Parks Blog

The backlash began when a POV (point of view) video of Tiana’s Bayou Adventure surfaced online. Fans quickly took to social media to express their disappointment with the ride’s lackluster experience. Many felt that Disney had caved to pressure to change Splash Mountain but delivered a particularly cheap and uninspired version that failed to capture the magic and excitement of the original.

One of the most bold critiques came from a fan who echoed the sentiments allegedly shared by Disney CEO Bob Iger after riding the attraction. “I agree with what Bob Iger reportedly said after riding it… ‘This is really boring,'” the fan stated, capturing the general consensus among many who had high hopes for the ride.

Another fan highlighted what they saw as a glaring omission in the ride’s design: “The greatest missed opportunity in Disney parks history is to leave out Facilier and not have ‘are you ready!???’ playing while going up the lift hill for the final drop.” This sentiment was shared by many who felt that the ride’s narrative and thematic elements were lacking, failing to deliver the immersive and memorable experience that Disney is known for.

The criticism continued with one fan remarking, “A multimillion-dollar Disney ride that looks… boring? I never thought I would see it.” This comment underscored the sense of disbelief among Disney enthusiasts who had come to expect a certain level of quality and excitement from the company’s attractions.

A log flume ride under testing, featuring empty log-shaped boats on a water track, with a sign stating "sorry, friends, we are ride testing only. opening this summer!" in a lush, green park setting.
Credit: Inside the Magic

Adding to the chorus of disappointment, another fan drew a comparison to another recent Disney failure: “This ride might die faster than the Star Wars hotel,” referencing the Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser that shut down permanently. This comparison highlighted the growing concerns about Disney’s ability to deliver on its promises and maintain its status as a leader in the theme park industry.

Perhaps the most biting critique came from a fan who took issue with the ride’s dialogue: “‘Let’s make you big because the bigger you are makes the bigger splash at the party’ has to be the worst line in the entirety of Disney’s history,” they said, referring to a particularly cringe-worthy moment in the ride. This comment encapsulated the frustration and disappointment felt by many who had hoped for a more polished and engaging experience.

A large rotating globe with the word "Universal" prominently displayed stands as the iconic entrance landmark for Universal Land. It is surrounded by lush greenery, mist, and white fences, with palm trees and park attractions visible in the background.
Credit: Aditya Vyas on Unsplash

The backlash against Tiana’s Bayou Adventure has raised serious questions about Disney’s current direction and its ability to compete with the increasingly impressive offerings from Universal Studios. While Disney has a long history of bouncing back from setbacks, the repeated missteps and underwhelming responses to its latest attractions suggest a deeper issue that needs to be addressed.

As Universal continues to innovate and push the boundaries of what a theme park can offer, Disney must find a way to recapture the magic and excitement that once set it apart. This will likely require a combination of bold new ideas, a renewed commitment to quality and storytelling, and a willingness to take risks and embrace change.

What do you think of the brewing competition between Disney World and Universal Orlando Resort? Let Inside the Magic know in the comments!

View Comments (28)