Are ‘Bluey’ Fans the New Bronies? Fanbase Remains Under Fire for Response To Recent Episode

in Disney, Entertainment, Movies & TV

Two animated dogs in a living room, one larger with a black mask and another smaller in a spacesuit, playfully interacting with tennis balls on the floor during a recent episode. Bluey Surprise episode.

Credit: Disney, Ludo Studio

Bluey, the beloved Australian children’s animated series, has recently found itself in the midst of a fervent fandom controversy. The show, known for its heartwarming portrayal of a Blue Heeler family, has engendered passionate discussions among viewers, particularly in online fan communities.

Adult Bluey fans have been a significant part of the show’s success, bringing enthusiasm and appreciation for the wholesome family dynamics portrayed in the series. However, this demographic has also found itself the subject of quite a bit of scandal within the Bluey fandom.

While some argue that adult fans contribute to the show’s popularity and engage positively with its themes, others criticize them for various reasons. One thing is clear – the love for Bluey transcends age barriers, uniting fans of all ages in their admiration for the heartwarming adventures of the Heeler family. However, how much love is it appropriate for a Bluey adult fan to have?

Three cartoon dogs, a brown and white dog named Bluey, a black and white dog, and a red dog, stand on a wooden platform in a grassy field with a clear sky.
Credit: Ludo Studios

The Dark Corners of ‘Bluey’s’ Fandom

One area of contention is the extent to which adult fans should engage with children’s content like Bluey. Some believe that adults should enjoy the show without being overly involved in fan communities or discussions to maintain the primary focus on the target audience – children.

On the other hand, adult fans argue that they have the right to express their love for the show and connect with like-minded individuals, regardless of age. This tension between inclusivity and respecting the intended audience age range is an ongoing debate in the Bluey fandom that reflects broader discussions in fan culture.

As the Australian TV show continued to grow in popularity as it began being played on Disney Junior, fans began drawing the comparison between the Bluey fanbase and the “Brony” fanbase. If you didn’t know, a “Brony” is a male fan of the children’s television series My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. The fanbase has faced harsh criticism for its sexualization of the children’s characters.

While the seeds of this debate have been planted since the show first found its audiences years ago, the controversy within the Bluey fandom has recently escalated after the release of the surprise Bluey episode aptly called “Suprise.”

In this episode, fans see a rare glimpse of Bluey in the future. We see the Blue Heeler family all grown up, with new lives and adventures of their own. It is an incredibly sweet and sentimental moment that instantly was a hit for audiences. However, most super fans were specifically caught up on one minute moment of the show where we see what appears to be Bluey’s child.

Related: Bluey’s “Baby Daddy” Breaks the Internet

Animated image of a large Bluey and black dog with wide eyes standing inside a house, looking through glass doors at a smaller dog outside who is peeking in.
Credit: Inside the Magic

Is the ‘Bluey’ Fandom Too Mature?

While many fans saw this moment and thought it was a sweet addition to the episode, some fans took this as a mission to find out who Bluey’s child’s father could be in the show. The conversation started out innocent enough, but some fans quickly dove very deep into finding out who the baby’s father could be.

This incident spurred a lot of fan-created content, such as fan art and fan fiction, based on some pretty adult themes. This spurred debates about the appropriateness of adults engaging with younger fans online, especially when discussing topics like paternity and adult relationships.

These discussions highlight the complexities of fan participation and the blurred lines between age-appropriate fan practices in a community centered around a children’s television show. While adult Bluey fans are absolutely entitled to discuss the show in their own spaces, they can also unintentionally expose younger fans to potentially inappropriate content.

A screenshot of a social media post featuring various cartoon-style sticker designs, including cute animals and Bluey characters, alongside comments and reactions from adult fans.
Credit: Screenshot by Inside the Magic

Where We Should Draw the Line

Is it unconventional for adults to be fans of Bluey, the popular children’s animated series? Some may view adult fans of the show with skepticism or confusion, questioning the appropriateness of grown individuals enjoying content primarily aimed at young children.

However, the reality is that Bluey has garnered a diverse fan base that includes adults who appreciate its humor, heartwarming messages, and clever storytelling. While some may argue that there is no harm in adults enjoying wholesome entertainment like Bluey, others believe that adult fans may be crossing a boundary by immersing themselves in content meant for a much younger audience.

Despite the debate surrounding adult Bluey fans, it is essential to consider that individuals have varied preferences when it comes to entertainment. Just like adults enjoy reading young adult literature or watching animated movies, being a fan of Bluey does not necessarily indicate anything unusual or inappropriate. In fact, embracing a show like Bluey can be a way for adults to connect with their inner child, appreciate the simple joys of life, and bond with their own children or family members over shared interests.

A cartoon image of Bluey, looking sad with tears in its eyes, sitting in a mystical pink-toned forest.
Credit: Ludo Studio

A Future Forward for Fans of All Ages

Ultimately, the question of whether adult Bluey fans are peculiar or not is subjective and largely depends on personal perspectives. Rather than labeling adult fans as “weird,” it may be more constructive to celebrate the diverse fan base that Bluey has attracted, recognizing that enjoyment of a show knows no age limits and can bring people of all ages together in appreciation of its delightful content.

It is imperative that fans call out any inappropriate behavior aimed at younger fans, as well as any hypersexualizing material of the show’s characters. In order to try to build a better image of the Bluey community, it is essential that the safety of child fans remains the utmost priority.

Overall, the controversy surrounding adult Bluey fans underscores the evolving nature of fandom in the digital age, where individuals of all ages can connect over shared interests and engage with content in diverse ways. While disagreements persist regarding the role of adult fans in the Bluey community, one thing remains certain – the passion and dedication of fans, no matter their age, continue to shape the cultural impact of this beloved animated series.

in Disney, Entertainment, Movies & TV

Be the first to comment!