Does Disney Have Too Many Passholders?

in Disneyland Resort, Walt Disney World

annual passholder slide


When Disney announced that a new Annual Pass Program would be coming to Disneyland Resort, thousands of former Annual Passholders — called Legacy Passholders — were excited to once again visit Disneyland as often as they wanted. They would need to make reservations to visit, but no longer having to pay each time they visited was a light at the end of a long, year-long closure tunnel.

Credit: Disney

Not long after the announcement of the return of Annual Passes, which are now called Magic Keys, Disney released the prices for Magic Keys and thousands of Guests were willing to shell out $1,400 for the Dream Key — the top-tier Magic Key with no blockout dates and free parking. Unfortunately, many of those same Guests now feel that they aren’t getting what they paid for.

Disneyland Magic Key
All Images Credit Disney

The Disneyland Resort Magic Key reservation calendar currently shows that there are almost no reservations left for the month of October and most days in November are either booked or only have Disney California Adventure as the starting Park — but there are still some weekdays where both Parks are available. December looks much the same, with a weekend reservation for Disneyland unavailable until the 19th.

Magic Key reservations
Credit: Screenshot Disneyland Website

While things aren’t quite as dire for Annual Passholders at Walt Disney World, the reservation system does make it difficult for Annual Passholders who live in the area to make a Park Pass reservation that isn’t weeks in advance. Disney World tends to be a big destination vacation for families who don’t live close, while Disneyland has a large majority of locals.

walt disney world watercraft transportation
Credit: Disney Parks

Unfortunately for those who live close to the Florida theme parks, getting a reservation can also be tough since they are booked months in advance by those coming from out-of-state, a lot of which may also be Annual Passholders. Disney has also not said how many reservations are set aside for Annual Passholders, as opposed to regular ticket holders or Disney World Resort Guests.

The reality of Annual Passholders and Magic Key Holders being unable to make reservations is beginning to beg the question, does Disney have too many Passholders?

epcot crowd levels
Credit: ITM Kelly C.

If Annual Passholders want, in theory, to be able to visit the Parks whenever they want, they have to pay well over $1,000 for the privilege. For that price, they want to be able to visit the Parks when they want, as often as they want. Now, sure, it stands to reason that maybe a day they want is booked, that happens. But a month? Six weeks? That doesn’t seem right in the heads of many APs.

disneyland crowd levels september
Credit: Inside the Magic

It might be time for Disney to think about pausing the sale of Annual Passes, especially in California. Yes, Disney needs to make up for the revenue that they lost during the theme park closures, but to continue to sell Annual Passes and Magic Keys when they potentially can’t be used for at least a month? Passholders are eventually going to put their foot down, stop buying, stop going, and Disney will end up losing money.

Do you think Disney has too many Annual Passholders and Magic Key Holders? Let us know in the comments!

CLICK HERE to book your Disney Resort vacation with our friends at Academy Travel – an EarMarked Diamond travel agency that can provide you with a free quote today!

View Comment (1)