Did a Carousel of Progress Character Retire to Haunted Mansion?

in Walt Disney World

haunted mansion theory

All images credit Disney

If you are a fan of Haunted Mansion and Walt Disney’s Carousel of Progress at Disney World, this theory is about to blow your mind.

carousel of progress
Credit: Disney

Personally, the two attractions are my absolute favorites of mine at Magic Kingdom, and now, the Disnerd in me is even more excited because there may be a connection between the two attractions.

If you have been on Walt Disney’s Carousel of Progress, of course, you know we follow the American family through the 20th century, but also, we get to see more than just the classic nuclear family of John (dad), Sarah (mom), Jim (brother), Patty (sister).

There is a grandmother, grandfather, and uncle that all appear throughout the ride as well. And the grandmother specifically has some funny moments in the show, especially when she is hiding her love of boxing from her husband.

carousel of progress
Credit: Disney

When Guests see the grandmother listening to music in one scene, we can see she is rocking back and forth on a rocking chair, which is identical to what one of the characters does in Haunted Mansion.

Thanks to The Mouselets (@themouselets) on TikTok, we can see a side-by-side comparison of both characters, and I have to say — it looks identical.

@themouselets

One of my favorite Disney secrets! #disneyfacts #disneysecrets #castmember #disneycollegeprogram #disneyvacationclub

♬ There’s a Great Big Beautiful Tomorrow – Rex Allen

In the Haunted Mansion scene, we can see another elderly lady rocking in her chair, just as the grandmother does in Carousel of Progress, and down to the hairstyle, the two look identical.

So, when I saw this video I thought… can this make sense? Well, let’s see.

carousel of progress
Credit: Disney

Related: New Live-Action ‘Haunted Mansion’ Film to Materialize 

For the grandmother from Carousel of Progress to be one of the 99 souls that reside in Haunted Mansion, morbidly, she would need to be dead. The final scene in Carousel of Progress takes place in 2000, so her death would logically need to happen at some point after that.

haunted mansion ghost
Credit: Disney

Ok, we have that timeline sorted, but what about Haunted Mansion? For this theory to be true, we need to be able to place Grandma Progress in Haunted Mansion at some point after 2000, in terms of the storyline.

So, let’s first find out the era in which Haunted Mansion takes place. Intitally, many may just assume it is older due to a lot of the Victorian era touches that are detailed throughout, but, as we saw in the 2003 live-action film, it seems that time is really irrelevant at Haunted Mansion because, for every new Guest, time technically freezes for them — Speaking in terms of what Guests know about the world once they die.

Related: Disney Shares Inside Look at Haunted Mansion Illusions

haunted mansion
Credit: Disney

Related: Should Disney Remove Hanging Body Scene from Haunted Mansion?

So, it seems that our grandmother in Carousel of Progress could very well be the old lady rocking in Haunted Mansion! And if it was, this would not be Disney’s first time connecting characters through attractions, as we have seen in the past through Disney’s Secret Society of Explorers and Adventurers. That being said, this is just a theory and has not been confirmed by Disney.

Do you think that the grandmother in Carousel of Progress could be the old lady in Haunted Mansion?

View Comments (9)