Comments for Opinion: “Star Wars Rebels” Has a Jedi Problem; Let’s Hope Lucasfilm Knows How to Fix It

Image Copyright Lucasfilm / Disney


  1. Oscar

    Mike Celestino, I was thinking of another animated Star Wars series that should accompanied with Star Wars Rebels and i want this to become reality.

    Star Wars: Resistance, a new animated Star Wars series made by Rainbow s.r.l., an Italian animation studio who made Winx Club and Huntik. It is a prequel to The Force Awakens.

    In my opinion, Disney should buy Rainbow s.r.l., Iginio Straffi would become president of a combined Italian-American company, Disney-Rainbow (which consist in two animation studios, Disney Television Animation and Rainbow s.r.l.), while Iginio’s wife, Joanne Lee would become both Vice Presidents and Chief Officer of Disney-Rainbow, replacing Eric Coleman.

    Can you imagine a full hour Star Wars block on Disney XD, with Star Wars Rebels and Star Wars: Resistance?

    1. Mike Celestino

      Sounds good to me!

    2. EricJ

      Oscar…WHY do you keep asking us to validate your imagination?

  2. Erik

    All excellent points, however, now I’m ever more confused about the timeline, as in this past weekends 2 parter is the comment about Skywalker??? Surely they are not referring to Vader at this point? He exists in the Rebels, so they must be talking of Luke, but if this predates Rogue, which predates Episode IV, how?????

    1. Hector

      Allow me to clarify, In the episode, Rex was referencing Anakin Skywalker. Both Saw Guerrera and Rex fought alongside Anakin and got to see him do some impressive things with the force in the Clone Wars animated series on Cartoon Network. This is why he made that “He’s no Skywalker” comment. No one knows about Luke’s existence in this series yet as it takes place a few years before Rogue One.

      1. Mike Celestino

        What he said!

  3. EricJ

    I’m not sure–Are you disappointed that a 10’s TV show ISN’T killing their characters off?

    1. Mike Celestino

      I don’t expect them to have killed them off already, just a little concerned that they may not satisfactorily explain their absence from the original trilogy time period, and worried that the powers that be may dilute the “Luke is the last remaining Jedi” plot point that made his journey so powerful. I hope I’m wrong.

      1. TEE

        They may kill of kanan but I doubt ezra will be killed of if they want to use him as Luke best friend in the movie. Ezra may abandon the jedi ways and the ghost crew he may also become like bendu

  4. Christina

    Perhaps Yoda’s comment to Luke is for Luke’s benefit, it is what personally motivates Luke, it may not be a comment as to whether Kannan and/or Ezra or other Jedi’s or Force-Sensitive characters are existing in the infinitely large expanse of the Star Wars Universe–ie. just because we dont hear about or see Kannan, Ezra or Sabine in Rogue One, or the original trillogy, doesnt mean they cannot be out there. Think of all the characters we have never met that exist. I think it would be tough to kill off any of the Rebels in the animated version, not because its targeting a younger audience (whatever I am 37), but like Ashoka, we have spent a lot of quality time with them and personally, I would rather have it left ambiguous. Seeing Jyn, Cassian, etc. sacrifice themselves for the cause was hard enough, and we had only gotten to know them for a short time, versus how much more time has been invested with the crew of the Ghost. The character overlaps into other stories are always cool, but again, it is an infinite galaxy, so stay optimistic!

    1. Greg

      I agree. And though Leia was not seemingly a full jedi, she did have SOME abilities, and in fact Yoda even told ghost Obi Wan that Luke wasn’t their last hope, but that there was another (Leia).
      So, it certainly could have been motivation for Luke. Also, since the galaxy seems to be randomly dotted with potential force users, it seems unlikely that at any given moment there are no Jedi out there, and Yoda would most certainly know that.

      1. Mike Celestino

        As another commenter noted below, there’s a big difference between a Force-sensitive individual or even a potential Jedi and a trained Jedi Knight. It would bug me if Ezra and Kana were still around for the period of ANH through ROTJ and were not enlisted in Luke’s battle against Vader and the Emperor, especially if Yoda already knew they existed, which he does.

  5. Casey

    Kanaan never became a Jedi as he was a padawan when he escaped Order 66, while he is training Ezra in the ways of the Jedi neither are actual jedis. Ashoka left the Jedi Order. Once Obi Wan was killed, Yoda was the last of the Jedi, not the last force sensitive being.

    1. DALON

      Kanan was elevated to full Jedi Knight in the middle of last season.

  6. Marie

    I’ve stated this elsewhere, but wondering what all of you think….Some people see Ezra as going to the dark side, but rather than go to the dark side, maybe Ezra forsakes being a force user and becomes Lor San Tekka ….the “explorer” in Force Awakens. Lor states that Leia would always be royalty to him when speaking with Poe revealing a familiarity with her from long ago. A loss of Kanan (even if ambiguous like Ahsoka) and threat of the Empire, could push Ezra to leave it all behind. He would also be contemporaries with Luke and Leia (having met Leia and Senator Organa) and, therefore, maybe would be the one trusted with the piece of the map leading to Luke’s whereabouts…..just a theory…..who knows, but you gotta love this stuff! We shall see!

    1. Mike Celestino

      Now that’s a very interesting theory! I like it a lot, but is Lor San Tekka a little too old by the time of TFA to be a grown-up Ezra? He’s certainly at least a couple decades older than Luke, but in Rebels timeline I feel like Ezra and Luke are maybe 2-3 years apart if that.

      1. Marie

        I agree. They are close in age. By the time of Force Awakens Luke and Leia are around 60. Rather than old, maybe Lor San Teka (Max Von Sedow) is just a little…hhmm….” weathered” from exploring. ;o)

  7. MykeTV

    I believe that Ezra will become a powerful force user with no alliance to Jedi or Sith. Remember, there are force users in the galaxy that do not practice the way of the Jedi or Sith. When Ezra was introduced in Rebels, he was a young force user with no alliance with anyone. He was driven by his hatred and confusion of what the Rebellion stands for and his fear of the Empire. Pair this theory with the casting of Benicio Del Toro in Episode VII. He could very much be cast as an older version of Ezra who is on a much different path than he was in Rebels, perhaps to avenge something that will take place later in the show. He will no longer be a Jedi.

    In many ways this parallels Maul’s journey, who was once part of the Sith order, then after being betrayed by the Sith, he went rogue and also has no alliance. It just so happens that Maul is trying to be Ezra’s mentor and confidante. I think their intertwining aspirations will also play a role in how the First Order and/or Knights of Ren enter the picture.

    As for the fate of Kanan, I look forward to seeing how this gets tied up, but I don’t have a good feeling about his survival.

    You mentioned no major deaths in Rebels… what about Ahsoka Tano?! She spanned the timeline of both the Clone Wars and Rebels series! Very major character with a huge impact to the storyline, especially the fact that she was killed by her former master, Anakin Skywalker aka Darth Vader.

    Between Ahsoka’s death, Ezra abandoning the Jedi order, and an some kind of conclusion for Kanan… I think this takes care of the remaining Jedi before A New Hope begins.

    I spend way too much time thinking about this stuff, lol.

    1. Mike Celestino

      This is all wonderful, Myke. I especially love the Benecio theory. But I’d say Ahsoka’s fate is a little bit more open-ended than to say she is definitively dead. Last we saw, she was walking into that temple after having fought Vader.

      And don’t worry about spending too much time thinking about Star Wars. That applies to plenty of us! 🙂

  8. Dave Thomas

    Given that the references to Hera and Chopper occur in R1 prior to the Battle of Scarif, and a Corellian VCX-100 that may well be the Ghost pops up in the battle, I’d like to see the series end with them arriving at the battle and… that’s it. Do they make it? Up to the viewer 🙂

  9. I am Robin Lee of the Maxfield Parrish Motif project. Twenty years ago I filmed and documented the senseless destruction of the iconic estate art studio of pop culture artist, Maxfield Parrish, look his work up. Filmmaker George Lucas said that it was the art work of Maxfield Parrish that directly inspired the feel and look of his Star Wars films, The Lucas Effect, page 282. It is now all over the internet.
    I have uncovered so many epic discoveries and I am trying to get this amazing story out to the masses and podcasts. Lucas will display his Maxfield Parrish collection in his new museum. My research and findings are vital and valuable to the art and Star Wars world. I am not tech savvy, I know how important anything Star Wars is, so please look into this story with decades of research and findings.
    * I do believe that Star Wars began in that art studio of Maxfield Parrish around 1904.
    I have other discoveries and yes they are epic.
    Thank you for your time, Robin Lee, Maine

  10. Wow, do I have an epic story out of the UK, new Star Wars info! This is really wonderful new info on Princess Leia, George Lucas and more, read it.
    ( The Game of Nerds origins of Star Wars the case for Maxfield Parrish).
    look it up!

Comments are closed.