Review: “Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides” returns the series to simpler fun of the first film

in Disney, Movies, Reviews

As the fourth installment in the series, “Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides” brings adventure back to the big screen. With a smaller budget and cast, its tight-knit story, more subtle humor, and focus on its biggest stars delivers a movie that will entertain and amuse those who have stuck with the “Pirates” series despite a few bumps along the way.

The first “Pirates of the Caribbean” film (“The Curse of the Black Pearl”) was a smash success, with Johnny Depp’s eccentric role as Captain Jack Sparrow leading the way in turning a classic Disney theme park attraction into a worldwide film phenomenon. The two sequels that followed (“Dead Man’s Chest” and “At World’s End”) did so in true Hollywood style, with a bigger budget, larger cast, and more special effects, raking in millions more at the box office. But while the profit made was big enough to excite any treasure seeker, it came at a cost. The first “Pirates” film is widely regarded as the best in the series, with the two sequels confusing many audiences with winding stories of pirate lords and voodoo spanning across both films.

But “Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides” takes the series back to where it began, with a smaller cast leading viewers through a much simpler story. Don’t take “smaller” and “simpler” as negatives. They’re quite the opposite, allowing viewers to sit back and follow along as Captain Jack seeks out the Fountain of Youth.

And “On Stranger Tides” is indeed the story of Captain Jack Sparrow. While the supporting main cast of Hector Barbossa (Geoffery Rush), Angelica (Penelope Cruz), and the infamous Edward “Blackbeard” Teach (Ian McShane) are fantastic, they are indeed supporting the antics of Depp’s Sparrow. Nearly every scene and story branch features Sparrow, either alone or playing alongside others, which is decidedly a good thing, as he’s exactly who audiences flock to “Pirates” films to see. Though admittedly Barbossa is as important to the “Pirates” saga as Sparrow, receiving plenty of screen time following a fun twist to his ongoing story arc, beginning with audiences wondering how he could possibly have wound up serving as captain of a king’s navy, a far stretch from piracy.

Surprisingly, the majority of the pirate crew seen in the previous three films is absent. Only Gibbs, Sparrow’s right-hand man, returns to this film, with the rest of the regulars replaced by Captain Blackbeard’s crew. These new roles support the story but are entirely forgettable. Only one of the new crew characters sticks out, but not always for the right reasons.

Also absent from “On Stranger Tides” are Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley). Assumed to be living happily ever after, their absence is not missed. Amidst the rough looking pirates, two young, attractive stars stand out. Sam Claflin plays the clergyman Phillip and Astrid Berges-Frisbey plays the intriguing mermaid Syrena. Both roles are important to the story, but ultimately minor, leaving the big moments to the big players.

The story of “On Stranger Tides” is the definition of adventure. Sparrow is following in the legendary footsteps of Ponce de Leon, seeking the famous Fountain of Youth. But in his fairly non-chalante quest, he quickly discovers he’s not the only one looking for it, as other interested parties visibly show their determination to be the first to reach it, each with his or her own reason. But to activate the Fountain’s magical properties, certain important items are needed and therein lies the bulk of the film’s adventure. It is a series of quests, each with its own trials.

In search of these important items, Sparrow is both pitted against and teamed up with his adversaries, depending on the immediate goal at hand. And, naturally, he approaches each situation with his trademark brand of humor. But not to worry, the slapstick humor that sent Sparrow running through the jungle tied to a giant fruit skewer in “Dead Man’s Chest” is completely absent from “On Stranger Tides.” In its place are plenty of one-liners and genuinely funny moments, none of which are groan-worthy. Some exchanges between Sparrow and Angelica (Depp and Cruz) are so witty and fast-spoken that many jokes might be missed entirely if audiences aren’t paying attention to every spoken word. And audiences need not worry about understanding Cruz’ dialogue spoken in her thick Hispanic accent. Ironically if anyone is difficult to understand it’s Depp, with many of his lines spoken like a true rum-soaked pirate.

While slapstick humor may have disappeared from this “Pirates” installment, bizarre circumstances are plenty. There are unexplained supernatural elements to be found throughout the film. But they can easily be brushed off in the spirit of adventure (or… perhaps more implied voodoo). Only one or two of Jack Sparrow’s infamous escape plans are overly outrageous, involving high-flying acrobatics only a monkey could achieve. (Then again, the monkey’s name is Jack, isn’t it?)

Visually, “Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides” feels intimate. While the biggest scenes feature crowds of a hundred or so, the majority of the film focuses in on small groups of characters, with some scenes relying completely on Depp’s talent to hold the audience’s attention on his own. Settings are easily interchanged, with nearly every scene set in a jungle, ship, cave, or on a beach. Special effects are few and far between, making them even more impressive by being used sparingly (unlike the overabundance of them in the previous two “Pirates” films).

“On Stranger Tides” is the first of the series to be shot and shown in 3D, a fun but ultimately unnecessary addition. The film looked better than most in 3D and did offer a few “wow” moments, but most were fleeting and forgettable. If given the choice, a 2D screening is likely preferred, offering a clearer view with less eye strain.

Out of the four “Pirates of the Caribbean” films thus far (and there’s sure to be more), “On Stranger Tides” easily slides into the second best. Nothing will top the first for originality, but this new film comes close to matching its simple senses of excitement and humor driven by Captain Jack, one of the most entertaining and unique characters to recently be introduced to the silver screen. And with a few references to the Disney ride the series is loosely based on, “On Stranger Tides” makes it clear that a pirate’s life is for everyone.


  1. Rob Stevens

    What’s interesting is that the movie is so heavily focused on Jack Sparrow, since the character wasn’t in the source material at all.

    Looking forward to this movie a lot, regardless! Everyone is saying that it’s the best since the first, and I didn’t enjoy the second or third films much.

    1. Ricky Brigante

      Great point! I haven’t read the original, but Sparrow is definitely the center of attention in this film.

      1. Robert F

        From the sounds of it, Pirates Of The Caribbean On Stranger Tides is VERY loosely based on Tim Powers’ 1980’s novel “On Stranger Tides” – there’s Blackbeard, voodoo magic, The Fountain Of Youth, and zombies, but the token Pirates Of The Caribbean characters have either replaced characters in the novel or just added in by writer Terry Rossio, along with other things like the mermaids and the missionary character.

        The funny thing is it seems Tim Powers was inspired somewhat by our favorite classic pirate attraction at Disneyland while writing his book! I’m glad Disney invited him to the Disneyland premiere of the film, and it turns out he showed up! (There’s a couple interviews on the black carpet with him you can find on Youtube)

        Here’s a video of an interview with Tim Powers on Youtube from around December where he talks about most of this and what led Disney to option the rights to his novel in order to adapt it into the PotC world. =]

        Great review btw Ricky! This is fantastic news, I’m more excited for this film than I was before! I was hoping the movie would return somewhat to the tone of the first film, even though I did enjoy the sequels – just not quite as much, and the first is much more rewatchable for me. (The sequels, I must say, did do one VERY good thing – it gave us the incredible Davy Jones character!)

        This definitely helped me out on deciding whether to see this in 2D or 3D – I’ve heard from others that the 3D makes this movie’s dimly lit scenes difficult to watch – if this is true, its a shame. James Cameron knew in order to deal with this problem, he’d have to saturate the colors very highly and adjust the brightness in every single scene in order to match the 3D glasses’ effect of darkening your vision. It confounds me why other filmmakers refuse to take a little time to apply this to all of their 3D films, especially this one, because the 3D on the trailer during the vistas/wide-open shots look INCREDIBLE.

        All in all, I’m looking forward to seeing this movie in one format or the other! =]
        AMC Downtown Disney Anaheim here we come! lol

        1. Ricky Brigante

          The outdoor, daytime shots do look excellent in 3D. But there are many interior scenes that were quite difficult to see, as they were VERY dark. I did wonder at times why those scenes were so poorly lit until I realized it was likely the 3D glasses causing them to be difficult to make out.

          A handful of effects shots are fun in 3D but are by no means enough of a reason to endure the potential eye strain of watching it that way. I certainly left the theater with my eyes tired.

  2. Austin Lewis

    I can’t wait until this comes out!I’ve been to one of the islands in Hawaii where they filmed part of this,so i get to see stuff i saw!i cant wait!I’ve been waiting since the D23 expo 2009!I cant wait!!

  3. Scott B

    Finally saw this yesterday. I tried (and failed) to see a non-3D showing of it. So I reluctantly saw the 3D version. I agree with Ricky’s review, but I will be less kind about the 3D. I found it abysmal. The problem is, these polarizing 3D lenses filter out light (at least the really cheap ones at my theater do). This movie had lots of dark scenes that made watching in 3D almost unbearable at times.
    Seriously, 3D more times than not gives you a blurrier / darker image for more money. But hey, at least things pop out of the screen. Right?!

  4. Damon

    I didn’t see Pirates of the Caribbean in 3D because I can’t stand that nonsense. Honestly, I loved the 2D Pirates! Johnny Depp was his funny pirate self and that’s what made me love it! Although I loved this movie, I don’t think they should make another, since that would really be pushing the amount of movies this series should have been. The new actors in this movie were a welcome addition too. I am really excited for this movie to come out, because I know that today, the Blockbuster Movie Pass was released! I am really excited because the Blockbuster Movie Pass will give customers a huge selection of DVDs like Pirates of the Caribbean, along with TV shows and games by mail. Since it is being offered by DISH Network (who is also my employer), there are 20 channels that are included with the Movie Pass in addition to the thousands of movies and shows that you can stream to your TV or PC! Blockbuster also has many stores that you can exchange DVDs at and Blu-Rays are included! For all that, I think $10 is such a great price. I already signed up for the Blockbuster Movie Pass, and now I will just wait until POTC to come out so I can see it again!

  5. POTC4

    the 4th one was the best one in all of them

  6. We’re a group of volunteers and opening a brand new scheme in our community.

    Your website offered us with helpful helpful information and paintings on .
    You a formidable task and our whole community will probably be thankful to you .

    Definitely believe which you stated . Your favorite reason seemed to be
    on the net easy thing to take note of . I tell you , i definitely get
    annoyed consider think worries clear that just do not recognize about .
    You controlled and defined everything managed to hit the nail
    on the top no need side effect , others could take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thank you

  7. We are a group of volunteers and opening a brand new scheme in our community.
    Your website provided us with valuable information and paintings on .

    You made ​​an impressive job and our whole community
    could be grateful to you .
    Definitely imagine that you stated . Your favorite reason seemed to be on the net easy factor to understand of .
    I tell you , i certainly annoyed same as any other people people think worries not recognize about .
    You controlled perfectly as out everything managed to hit the nail on the top without having side-effects , other folks could take a signal.
    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

Leave a Reply