Comments for Carl May Have Been Dead the Entire Time During ‘Up’


Credit: Disney


  1. Barry

    Another one of these “he/she was really dead for 95% of the movie” theories? This is just another variant on the “it was just a dream”. Sorry, this isn’t The Sixth Sense and it only makes sense if there is some actual reveal at the end of the movie. Given that there wasn’t, it’s purely unwarranted speculation and goes against everything the creative team has shown us on the screen and in off-screen interviews, etc.

    1. EricJ

      And apparently, every one at Russel’s Wilderness Explorer meeting can see dead people, when Carl gives him his badge and the Ellie Grape-Pop Medal of honor…

      Sorry, this one’s as looney as M. Night Shamalyan having a few drinks at the Golden Globes and saying “Oh yeah, the mom was dead too (hic!)”

    2. SG

      Well said! I love this movie as it is.

  2. Stacy

    I am so sick of these … they were dead the whole time theories. Let people enjoy the story. Life is hard enough as it is. This is getting ridiculous.

  3. It’s a Wonderful Life!!! Don’t see it.

  4. Unless the Writers or Directors reveal this “type” of info can we PLEASE give this Garbage a rest.

Comments are closed.