2
Credit: Marvel StudiosDisney has spent the past few years reshaping the MCU in ways that keep fans on their toes. The studio has introduced new characters, bid emotional farewells to longtime favorites, and replaced major heroes with surprising replacements.
Now, Disney has done it again. Another Captain America has entered the Marvel spotlight, and fans aren’t entirely sure whether to cheer, worry, or simply brace themselves for whatever comes next. It’s a reminder that this legendary mantle has become more fluid than ever, and every new version adds another layer to the larger Marvel story.
The Original Captain America: Chris Evans’ Defining Legacy
Before exploring the newest hero picking up the shield, it’s impossible not to revisit Captain America, who changed everything. Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers became the heart of the MCU. From Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) through Avengers: Endgame (2019), he helped anchor the entire franchise with a mix of sincerity, strength, and quiet determination.
His journey—from a scrawny kid with a big heart to a world-saving super soldier—remains one of Marvel’s most emotional long-form arcs. Evans’ story ended with Steve choosing peace over battle, returning to the past to finally live the life he’d been denied. It was touching, final, and widely considered a near-perfect sendoff. That moment also opened the door for Marvel to ask the big question: Who becomes Captain America next?
John Walker: Marvel’s Attempt at a Captain America Replacement
Marvel didn’t waste much time showing fans that not every successor fits the symbol. John Walker (Wyatt Russell) arrived in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier as the government’s pick for a new Captain America. On paper, he seemed like the ideal candidate—decorated, determined, and willing to take on the responsibility. In practice, Walker quickly proved he lacked the humility and moral compass that defined Steve Rogers.
His meltdown on the world stage became one of the MCU’s most shocking moments, and it effectively ended his claim to the shield. Walker now operates as a member of the Thunderbolts, making him a fascinating “what could have been” in the Captain America lineage. He wasn’t the right replacement, but he added significant contrast to what the mantle truly requires.
Sam Wilson: The Captain America Chosen by Steve Rogers
Of course, the rightful heir has always been Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie). Steve chose him for a reason, trusting Sam’s compassion, steadiness, and ability to inspire others. Sam’s evolution from the Falcon to Captain America has been one of the MCU’s most rewarding journeys. He fully stepped into the role in Captain America: Brave New World, delivering a grounded and hopeful version of the character that fans have come to appreciate.
His story is far from over, either. Sam is already set to return in Avengers: Doomsday, where he will stand among Earth’s Mightiest Heroes as their new shield-bearing leader. In many ways, he represents the future of Captain America in live-action projects—and Marvel has treated his story with weight and care.
Beyond the MCU: Captain Americas in Other Marvel Projects
But the Captain America conversation doesn’t stop with the main MCU timeline. Marvel projects outside live-action continue to experiment with different interpretations of the character. Animated shows, LEGO specials, and various spinoffs often bring back voice actors who’ve portrayed the hero for years. That’s where Disney’s newest switch-up comes into play.
Two Captain Americas Return in a New Disney+ Project
Disney’s latest Marvel project, LEGO Marvel Avengers: Strange Tails, introduces fans to another Captain America moment—this time through animation. The special, released on November 14, features a pair of returning voice actors stepping back into their star-spangled roles.
Roger Craig Smith once again voices Steve Rogers/Captain America. Smith has become a familiar sound for longtime Marvel fans, having voiced Steve across shows like Spidey and His Amazing Friends, LEGO Marvel Avengers: Code Red, and Avengers Assemble.
His performance continues to keep the spirit of classic Cap alive in the animated realm. Ogie Banks also returns to voice Sam Wilson’s Captain America, a role he previously played in LEGO Marvel Avengers: Mission Demolition. This time, Sam even showcases a revived costume concept that was previously excluded from earlier projects, offering fans a fun nod to alternate design ideas.
A Wild Adventure Featuring Two Captain Americas
In this Disney+ exclusive, the Avengers face a hilariously chaotic threat: magically enhanced cats unleashed by an influencer desperate to go viral. Both Captain Americas—Rogers and Wilson—fight side by side, joined by heroes like Iron Man, Hulk, Black Panther, and Thor. The chaos doesn’t stop there, as the Avengers eventually find themselves battling the X-Men as well.
It’s over-the-top, funny, and classic LEGO Marvel, but it also marks yet another chapter in the growing list of Captain America portrayals across Disney projects. With both Smith and Banks returning, the notable highlights include the numerous actors who have stepped into the shield-bearing role over the years.
Are Fans Feeling Captain America Fatigue?
With so many versions of the hero appearing across different platforms, some fans are starting to feel overwhelmed. It’s not that the new Captain Americas aren’t enjoyable—many of them are. Sam Wilson’s run has been inspiring, John Walker added tension and complexity, and animated versions bring creativity and nostalgia.
But even with all these new interpretations, one thing remains true: Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers will always hold a unique place in fans’ hearts. His portrayal laid the foundation for what Captain America means in the MCU, and no matter how many new versions emerge, his legacy keeps the symbol grounded.
What This Means for Captain America’s Future
Disney’s latest Captain America switch-up adds a new chapter to a legacy that keeps expanding in unexpected ways. From Evans’ unforgettable portrayal to Sam Wilson’s continued rise, from Walker’s explosive attempt to the animated world’s dual Caps, the mantle has become more flexible than ever.
Whether fans feel excited or overwhelmed, one thing is clear: Captain America isn’t slowing down. Disney continues to explore every corner of this hero’s potential—and this newest selection proves that the shield still has plenty of stories left to tell.