Credit: Taha, Unsplash / Canva / edited by ITMWhen people think of Disney and Disney+, they think of endless options. From animated classics to Marvel epics and galaxy-spanning Star Wars sagas, the streaming service is supposed to be the vault that never closes. But what happens when a show that fans loved is suddenly erased? That’s exactly what happened not long ago, and now one of those “lost” shows is making a comeback.
Disney’s library has always been its crown jewel, but the company’s management of that library has changed in surprising ways. For fans who have felt the sting of their favorite series disappearing, this comeback feels like a small victory. Before diving into the details of the revival, it’s worth remembering just how big Disney+ has been in shaping the streaming world.
Disney+ and Its Biggest Wins
When Disney+ first launched, it was instantly boosted by blockbuster hits. WandaVision took the Marvel Cinematic Universe into bold new territory, blending sitcom nostalgia with superhero drama. Loki became a fan favorite for its Multiverse mischief and Tom Hiddleston’s charisma.
The Mandalorian gave Star Wars fans something fresh and compelling while introducing the world to Grogu—better known as Baby Yoda. Even lighter fare, like High School Musical: The Musical: The Series, carved out its dedicated following, showing Disney+ wasn’t afraid to experiment with tone.
These shows set the bar high, convincing fans that Disney+ would be the ultimate destination for original content. But as the years passed, not every show enjoyed a long run. Some were cancelled outright, while others suffered an even stranger fate: being completely removed, leaving nowhere for fans to revisit them.
When Disney Started Purging Its Own Content
In 2023, Disney+ shocked subscribers by purging several original titles. The move wasn’t just underperforming projects—some shows had loyal audiences and solid reviews. It was primarily financial, with Disney opting to save money by cutting excess expenses.
Among the victims of this purge was a fan-favorite series that had already been cut short by cancellation. The frustration wasn’t just about the show ending—it was about it vanishing completely. If you missed it while it was live on Disney+, there was no legal way to watch it. Fans feared it would be lost to the Disney vault forever.
The Blacklisted Series Makes an Epic Return
That show was The Mysterious Benedict Society, a clever and heartfelt adventure series based on the beloved children’s books. The show launched in 2021, earned positive reviews, and scored a second season in 2022. But in January 2023, Disney cancelled it. Then, during the infamous May 2023 purge, both seasons were removed entirely.
For two years, The Mysterious Benedict Society existed in limbo. Fans posted on social media, hoping for a miracle, but the odds seemed slim. And yet, here we are in 2025 with that miracle becoming real. Starting October 5, both series seasons will stream on Wonder Project, a new service launching as an add-on to Amazon Prime Video.
Disney’s Other Purged Projects
The Mysterious Benedict Society isn’t the only casualty of Disney’s cost-cutting that has found a new home. Other titles have resurfaced in different places, reminding fans that even when Disney shuts a door, another streaming service might crack open a window.
Take Genius: MLK/X, a National Geographic series about Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. After it was scrubbed from Disney+ and Hulu, it appeared on Prime Video and Tubi. Then there was Marvel’s Runaways, originally a Hulu show that later joined Disney+. After the purge, it found new life on the CW, delighting longtime fans.
Some movies also slipped out of Disney+ and only popped up elsewhere. Stargirl is now streaming on Amazon Prime Video and YouTube TV. Magic Camp landed on YouTube TV. Even less successful projects like Cheaper by the Dozen (2022) live on through digital purchase options across platforms like Amazon and Apple TV.
These examples show a strange pattern: Disney might not see value in hosting these titles, but other companies recognize their appeal, even if it’s niche.
Why This Matters for Fans
At first glance, it might feel like just another corporate shuffle—one service loses a show, another picks it up. But for fans, this is more personal. Disney built its reputation on the promise of preserving its classics. To see content vanish broke that trust. That’s why seeing The Mysterious Benedict Society return matters. It’s not just about convenience—it’s about restoring something unfairly taken away.
It also highlights the evolving streaming wars. Fans can no longer assume that a Disney+ original will stay on Disney+. Content strategies are shifting rapidly; sometimes, even faith-based platforms like Wonder Project are stepping up to provide a new home.
A Second Chance at Mystery and Adventure
The story of The Mysterious Benedict Society reminds us how quickly the media landscape can change. Once “purged” and presumed gone for good, the series has found new life on Wonder Project. For Disney, it may have just been a financial decision. For fans, it’s proof that beloved shows can survive—even thrive—outside the walls of the Disney vault.
As other purged titles reappear in unexpected places, it’s clear that this streaming era will be defined as much by resurrection as by removal. Disney may have moved on, but for viewers who cherished The Mysterious Benedict Society, October 5 can’t come soon enough.