Another Hogwarts Professor Speaks Out on JK Rowling, Calls Her "Too Harsh"

Comments for Another Hogwarts Professor Speaks Out on JK Rowling, Calls Her “Too Harsh”

McGonagall, Sprout, and Dumbledore together in the hallway of Hogwarts

Credit: Video Screenshot, 'Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets', Warner Bros.

📣 Add your voice to the conversation! insidethemagic.raptive.com

What stood out to you in this article? Do you agree, disagree, or have a fresh perspective to add? Drop your thoughts below and spark a discussion! 💬🔥

Be the first to comment

18 Comments

  1. Anthony

    I say ….. let her have an opinion. She has a right to it! As for all these Virtue Signallers….. who said you had to counter act her?? I say – shut up, and go crawl back under your rock!

    1. Jenna

      I agree. Let Miriam Margolyes have her opinion.

      1. Carter

        Beat it, Jenna

    2. JN

      The world needs love, not hate. Being trans is not a crime. Unfortunately, I can no longer support anything JK does.

      1. Carter

        You’re scum, JN. Where you’re going you’ll find out how being woke is actually a crime.

        1. Bart

          Poor Carter…. so unhappy. It’s going to be alright little boy.

          1. JD

            It’s going to be so much watching you cry when you’re deported

  2. David

    I don’t think she’s doing anything wrong! She’s entitled to her opinions as well as these trans people. I personally never really chose a side in it until recently. I served so other had the right laid out in the bill rights. But as of late I have started to shift side an am no longer staying neutral on this subject anymore due to the actions of many trans people. I have the right to my beliefs but when you start to push your beliefs on me an try to tell me how I have to change my life an beliefs to aline with your beliefs or include yours in mine. That’s when I draw the line! I fought to maintain my rights as well as everyone else’s. But your rights don’t over ride my rights nor does that give you the rights to force yours beliefs on me. I have had issues with trans trying to tell me how I have to speak to or about them so they could maintain their safe space or not hurt their feelings or beliefs. Well that isn’t happening anymore! When you try an force your opinions or beliefs on me you will get put back in your place where you belong. I don’t care if your trans or what ever you want to call yourself. But keep to yourself an in your own lane an don’t force yourself into my lane an try to push me around in it! Because I will push back using the same amount of respect or lack there of as you try to use when you come at me! You want respect from me then you dam sure better give it to me as well! An that’s part of the mental problems here. Where a certain group of men an women think they have the right to force the rest of us to follow their belief systems. When all they actually have is the right to choose their own beliefs an live as such without hindering or forcing them on to others who choose to believe differently then the few with the non majority of beliefs! So to those who choose to be trans. Go ahead an live your life but don’t try an force your style of life into other who choose not to live like that! It’s your choices your right to live like that not ours! So stop trying to override everyone else’s rights with yours!

    1. CAP

      You nailed as an Army Veteran myself.

      I am tired of all the wokeness that has been thrown at me as a conservative.

      Do not push your liberal agenda on me.

  3. Carter

    I stand with Rowling!! She as well as the rest of the normal people have every right to be against the “woke community”. We’re sick of woke being rubbed in our faces and expected to give into their disgusting ways. Woke people can go start their own planet elsewhere. Eventually they’ll die out since they can’t have kids, lol!

    1. Woke Up

      We don’t rub woke in your face, we wipe it.

    2. Dan F.

      There have been dozens (hundreds ???) of studies already that have concluded that there are only two genders. There have been studies that show real hormonal changes begin in males as early as 3 years, with others showing that the gender specific roots are present at birth. (immutable, I may add) While the seven percent that are LGBwhatever claim they have rights, there are NO positive studies that demonstrate they are any different PHYSICALLY/GENETICALLY from the two accepted genders. And while current studies show that there is no mental root, one has only to surmise that that is the only conclusion left. YOU CANNOT CHANGE GENDERS !!! Born male, die male !!!
      And BTW, the whole gender confusion issue has existed in all histories of civilizations with the same regection !!!! Nothing has changed !

      1. Dan F.

        Sorry….rejection

      2. MC

        Okay, which gender is a hermaphrodite, then? How about someone born without reproductive organs?

    3. CAP

      I agree with you 100% percent

  4. Anne

    I feel sorry that JK Rowling has to deal with trash like that. She deserves better. You have my support, JK!

  5. Bart

    It’s called consequences.

  6. MC

    I do not agree with everything that has been done, using trans people as an excuse, like the attacks on people who played Hogwarts Legacy, or the recent attacks, because Hunter isn’t going to be Zelda. I, also, agree, that female-identifying trans should not compete in women’s sports, due to physiology. However, I do support the trans community. We need to find better solutions for them to live happy lives as the gender they feel comfortable as, not just pretend they don’t exist. However, trans people need to remember that this is still new to a lot of people, and there are people who will take advantage of beneficial trans legislation, and be patient as things are figured out to protect everyone. Selfishness never helps anyone.

Add Your Voice

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.