A spoiler-free “Mary Poppins Returns” review from a “Mary Poppins” superfan

in Disney, Movies, Movies & TV

Mary Poppins Returns review

Disney’s “Mary Poppins Returns,” the long-awaited continuation of “Mary Poppins” (1964), finally arrives in theaters on December 19, fifty-four years after the original movie’s release. As someone who has seen “Mary Poppins” hundreds of times (literally), I can say “Mary Poppins Returns” feels entirely new yet wonderfully familiar — an almost impossible task for a sequel to such a beloved Disney classic.

When I say I’m a “Mary Poppins” superfan, that’s not an exaggeration. As a child, I drove my father insane by begging to watch the movie back-to-back, three times a day. It’s no surprise that in 2013, he refused to see “Saving Mr. Banks” with me. “It’s about ‘Mary Poppins’!” I said, but he pretended not to hear me.

So, when I heard a sequel was on the way, I was extremely excited but knew this wouldn’t be the same as “Mary Poppins.” Without the involvement of Walt Disney and Julie Andrews and the music of the Sherman Brothers, how could it be? This is a new story, but the spirit of “Mary Poppins” remains.

Set about 20 years after the first movie, Michael Banks (Ben Whishaw) now has three children of his own (Nathanael Saleh, Pixie Davies, and Joel Dawson). He still lives at 17 Cherry Tree Lane, Ellen (Julie Walters) is still the housekeeper, and Admiral Boom (David Warner) still keeps time next door. Jane Banks (Emily Mortimer) is also grown-up, an independent woman who would make Winnifred Banks proud. But the family has suffered a personal loss, and to make matters worse, they’re at risk of losing 17 Cherry Tree Lane to foreclosure.

Enter Mary Poppins (Emily Blunt). During the buildup to her big entrance, you can’t help but feel emotional, like an old friend is returning. From the moment she arrives, it’s clear Blunt is not just doing an imitation of Julie Andrews in the role; it’s her own version of Mary Poppins, but it feels like the same person.

In the 1964 movie, Dick Van Dyke played Bert, friend and dance partner to Mary Poppins. In this movie, Lin-Manuel Miranda essentially has to follow in Van Dyke’s footsteps as Jack, a lamplighter who’s familiar with Mary Poppins and her magical ways. Blunt and Miranda have great fun together on screen, especially during the gorgeous 2D-animated song and dance number.

The entire 2D animation sequence is stunning and funny, and it’s a welcome throwback to an old-school style that we don’t see on screen anymore. In fact, according to director Rob Marshall, animators had to be brought out of retirement to create that sequence. Plus, the penguins from “Jolly Holiday” return for a brand-new dance routine.

Blunt and Miranda perform “A Cover is Not the Book”

As for the music, the soundtrack doesn’t feature instant classics like the original movie and there are fewer musical moments overall (excluding the overtures, there are 9 new songs in “Mary Poppins Returns,” compared to 16 songs in “Mary Poppins”). But there are a few gems, especially “Trip a Little Light Fantastic,” which is this movie’s equivalent to “Step in Time.” This is possibly the best moment in the film, coming closest to “Mary Poppins” perfection. The song features Jack, Mary Poppins, the Banks children, and a slew of toe-tapping Leeries, otherwise known as Jack’s fellow lamplighters. It’s a big, joyful sequence with fun lyrics (“So when your troubles are incessant/Simply be more incandescent/For your light comes with my lifetime guarantee”) that will leave you with an enormous smile on your face. Likewise, “Nowhere to Go But Up,” sung by everyone in the main company, is a spirit-lifting tune.

Blunt in “Trip a Little Light Fantastic”

Early on, it was made clear that Julie Andrews would not make a cameo in “Mary Poppins Returns,” but she did give her blessing to the movie and casting of Emily Blunt. Though part of me wished she would make an appearance, her reason for turning it down made sense. If she had suddenly appeared on screen, it would have been impossible to go on believing the story when the “real” Mary Poppins was right there in front of us.

Luckily, Dick Van Dyke’s cameo fit seamlessly into the new story. I knew he’d be playing Mr. Dawes, Jr., the son of the character he played in addition to Bert in the first movie, because I’d already cried happy tears when he was featured dancing on a desk in the trailer. Just like Mary Poppins’ big entrance, you can tell exactly when Van Dyke is about to appear, and he makes the whole thing feel full-circle and wonderful.

Also revealed in the trailer, Meryl Streep and Angela Lansbury appear in the movie as Mary’s cousin Topsy and The Balloon Lady, respectively. As expected, they both elevate the movie to another level of joy. Colin Firth’s role as William Weatherall Wilkins, the new director of Fidelity Fiduciary Bank, felt a bit out of place in the world of “Mary Poppins,” but Firth was great, as always.

“Mary Poppins Returns,” unlike the first movie, features more of a traditional plot. There are even a couple of high-stakes, all hands on deck moments, whereas, in the original, the “scariest” moment was Jane and Michael running through the streets of London after fleeing from the bank with their tuppence.

The first movie is all about the fleeting nature of childhood, and Bert drives that point home to Mr. Banks by singing, “You’ve got to grind, grind, grind at that grindstone/Though childhood slips like sand through a sieve/And all too soon they’ve up and grown/And then they’ve flown/And it’s too late for you to give/Just that spoonful of sugar to help the medicine go down.” There’s no real villain in “Mary Poppins”; Mr. Banks just can’t see past the end of his nose. Once he does, it’s time for Mary Poppins to move on.

“Mary Poppins Returns” is more about how we respond to things outside of our control, like grief and hardship, which affects kids and adults alike. When bad things happen, when life and other people bring us down, how do we hold on to that sense of childhood joy? It’s not easy, but thankfully we have Mary Poppins to remind us.

Now, for my fellow “Mary Poppins” superfans, here’s a list of Easter eggs I spotted in the movie. Skip this section if you want to be surprised!

Easter eggs in “Mary Poppins Returns” (Skip if you want to be totally spoiler-free!)

  • In the attic, you’ll see the snowglobe from “Feed the Birds” and the toy blocks spelling out “Mary Poppins” from “A Spoonful of Sugar”
  • The kite Michael throws away is the same kite from “Mary Poppins”
  • When Mary Poppins arrives at 17 Cherry Tree Lane, she reminds Michael “we are still not a codfish” and notices Jane is still prone to giggling; an instrumental version of “A Spoonful of Sugar” and a few notes from “The Perfect Nanny” play in the background
  • Mary Poppins wears a hat with a robin on it, a possible nod to the animatronic robin from “A Spoonful of Sugar”
  • During Topsy’s song “Turning Turtle,” Meryl Streep spins a weathervane, which signaled Mary Poppins’ arrival in the original movie
  • Karen Dotrice, who played Jane Banks in “Mary Poppins,” speaks to grown-up Jane on the street and says goodbye with “Many thanks, sincerely,” a line from the “The Perfect Nanny” song
  • Mr. Dawes, Jr. (Dick Van Dyke) begins to tell the Banks kids the “wooden leg named Smith” joke from the first movie
  • During “Nowhere to Go But Up,” listen for notes from “Let’s Go Fly a Kite” and “A Spoonful of Sugar”

Disney’s “Mary Poppins Returns” opens in theaters on December 19, and you can watch the trailer below.

Also be sure to check out the costume and props display from the El Capitan Theatre

15 Comments

  1. Candy

    Love your synopsis! Brought a rush of wonderful memories. We will definitely include a trip to the theatre Christmas week ❤️

  2. Elizabeth

    I really expected more of the movie. And not featuring supercalifragilistic was a total deception. I liked the first movie a lot more.

  3. lala

    Don’t forget about the toppins that Michael gave his Dad come full circle! I truly loved that!

Trackbacks

  1. Disney-inspired "Mary Poppins" beauty collection is practically perfect in every way
  2. "Cinderella" joins iconic Disney films in National Film Registry
  3. Your ultimate "Mary Poppins" fan guide
  4. Disney-inspired "Mary Poppins" collection available at Penneys stores in Ireland
  5. "Mary Poppins Returns" world premiere -- see the stars at Disney's red carpet event
  6. The new "Mary Poppins Returns" collection from Kipling is a limited-edition treat for Disney fans
  7. "Mary Poppins Returns" Funko Rock Candy, Vynl, and Pop! figures revealed
  8. Limited edition Mary Poppins doll brings a spoonful of sugar to shopDisney
  9. Mark your calendars! These are the Disney movies we can look forward to in 2019
  10. "Mary Poppins Returns" features Hidden Mickeys in nod to Disneyland
  11. How Disney revived the iconic "Feed the Birds" snow globe for "Mary Poppins Returns"
  12. Watch the full "Trip a Little Light Fantastic" song and dance sequence from "Mary Poppins Returns"

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.